Propel Equals Separate but Unequal Commission
Pittsburgh, PA: In response to today’s introduction in City Council of the ordinance to establish Propel Pittsburgh, the Pennsylvania League of Young Voters calls for the Mayor of the City of Pittsburgh to adopt a meaningful youth policy rather than continuing to create more toothless unfunded commissions. Young people do need to have a meaningful voice in city governance, but the Propel Pittsburgh Commission is at best redundant and at worst an autocratic attempt to disfranchise already active young Pittsburghers.
Pittsburgh already has several organizations designed to engage and empower young people including The Pennsylvania League of Young Voters, PUMP, and Progress Pittsburgh. Creating a commission to represent young people not only replicates the efforts of longstanding organizations like Progress Pittsburgh and PUMP but worse yet, it has been done without any attempt at dialogue with these groups. The creation of this commission has been done in a complete vacuum.
Rather than create another commission we ask that the Mayor, who should understand the priorities of young people, pledge to appoint a diversity of young people to all city commissions, boards, and authorities. Creating a commission on women, youth or people of color is not the same thing as integrating women, young people and people of color into government and making policy decisions based on their best interest.
We should not be creating a separate and unequal commission because the interests of young Pittsburghers span the already existing boards and commissions. The City Planning Commission, the Ethics Hearing Board, the Citizens Police Review Board, the Housing, Parking, Water and Sewer Authorities, and all the commissions, boards and authorities hold relevance for the city’s young population. More importantly retaining and attracting young people depends on the decisions these bodies make every day. Having a separate commission to make recommendations further distances, disenfranchises and alienates the very people it is meant to include. Should the Mayor decide to prioritize youth representation on all commissions, the League of Young Voters, would be happy to assist in the nomination process. We would urge the Mayor to consult Progress Pittsburgh and PUMP for their recommendations as well.
Should this commission be created we suggest rethinking the make-up as well. The unwieldy size, 35 members, will impact the ability of the commission to meet and come to a consensus. Beyond the size, we strongly urge the members are more proportional appointed. As it stands, 75% of the members will be appointed by the mayor. A better structure would be to have equal number of nominees from each city council member and the Mayor’s office. Two nominees, one female and one male, from the Mayor and from each city council member would create a commission of twenty members guaranteed to represent the city geographically. We also strongly urge members to reflect the city’s diversity in other areas as well.
Tags:
pa league of young voters,
Pittsburgh City Council,
Propel Pittsburgh